ANN ARBOR—Antiracist and feminist movements often fail to advocate for the rights of Black women, who are less likely than white women to be regarded as a “typical woman” and viewed much the same as Black men, according to new University of Michigan study.
“Black women are often overlooked in people’s conversations about racism and sexism even though they face a unique combination of both of these forms of discrimination simultaneously,” said lead researcher Stewart Coles, a doctoral candidate in the U-M Department of Communication and Media. “This ‘intersectional invisibility’ means that movements that are supposed to help Black women may be contributing to their marginalization.”
The research was published online this week in the American Psychological Association journal Translational Issues in Psychological Science. The study was conducted online with more than 1,000 participants from the United States who were asked whether 41 positive or negative stereotypical attributes (such as hostile, sexually promiscuous or determined) were associated with different races or genders. Participants were told that their responses were not an admission that they believed these stereotypes so they would answer honestly.
Some participants were asked about stereotypical attributes just for men and women or for Black people or white people. Then other groups were asked about a combination of race and gender (Black women, Black men, white women, white men). The clustering of the responses showed how Black women were viewed in relation to the other groups.
The typical woman was considered to be much more similar to a typical white woman than a typical Black woman. Black women and Black men also were considered to be more similar to each other than to white women or white men.
“The operative word in defining how similar to other groups Black women are is more ‘Black’ and less ‘women,'” Coles said.
The underdifferentiation of Black women from Black men may help explain why Black women face similar rates of racial disparities in traffic stops and arrests, but antiracist movements often focus on Black men in the fight against police brutality, said Josh Pasek, one of the researchers on the study and an associate professor of communication studies and faculty associate at the U-M Center for Political Studies.
“This is reflected both in terms of the victims of brutality who are highlighted and whose voices receive the most attention,” he said. “In this moment, we can see how much more attention has been paid to the murders of Ahmaud Arbery and George Floyd than the murder of Breonna Taylor.”
Arbery, a 25-year-old Black man, was shot dead in February after being chased by three white men as he jogged through a neighborhood in Brunswick, Georgia. Taylor, a 26-year-old Black woman was shot and killed by police in her Louisville, Kentucky, apartment in March. Floyd, a 46-year-old Black man was killed during an arrest in Minneapolis in May. His death set off protests across the country.
Previous research has found that Blackness is associated with masculinity, leading to errors when categorizing Black women’s gender or recognizing Black women’s faces. Other studies have found that Black women and girls are more associated with threat and danger than are white women and girls.
Feminist movements that focus only on issues that predominantly affect white women without addressing racialized sexism ignore the needs of Black women, who face higher rates of police abuses, including sexual violence, Coles said. Previous research also has found that Black women experience much higher rates of domestic and sexual abuse from partners than white women, and Black women are less likely to report this violence than white women.
Feminist and antiracist movements should include Black women in leadership roles and advocate for the rights of Black women, Coles said.
“The key often starts with listening to Black women about their concerns and what their needs are and then delivering accordingly,” he said.
Three out of four study participants were white, while 8% were Black, 8% were Hispanic and 5% were Asian. The responses weren’t analyzed based on the ethnicity or gender of the participants because the study wasn’t examining whether the participants endorsed specific stereotypes themselves.
“Previous research suggests that members of marginalized groups are aware of stereotypes of their groups,” Coles said. “Thus, they would likely report the same awareness of stereotypes as would members of other groups.”
Jared Wadley, U-Michigan, 734-834-7719, email@example.com
Bryan Goodman, APA, 202-336-6176